Dream Theater: The Creepy Mike Portnoy Imposter

The Creepy Mike Portnoy Imposter

I’ve covered a lot of imposter stories on
my channel including the Nikki Sixx, The Don

Henley and Rikki Rocket imposters.

But, the Mike Portnoy imposter is by far one
of the stranger stories and that’s what

we’re going to discuss in today’s video.

Former Dream Theater Drummer Mike Portnoy
is considered by some, to be one of greatest

drummers around today so it probably seemed
like a bad person to choose if you were an


This story starts in 2003.

People around new york city started noticing
a man claiming to be Portnoy who was heavily

medicated and intoxicated, wandering around
the City.

Soon enough, the drummer’s website would
be inundated with stories from people who

met the imposter.

The first story that surfaced about the imposter
involved a man named Carlin Langley who went

out to a gay bar in new york city around february
of 2003.

It was there Langley met a man claiming to
be Portnoy.

Langley who had never heard of dream theater
or Portnoy would tell the New York Post

“He told me he’d just come back from Japan
where he’d signed an endorsement deal with

a drum manufacturer, He had a lot of detailed
information about Portnoy’s life” he’d remember.

After a several drinks, the pair returned
to Langley’s apartment, where they “were


“according to the paper and the next morning
the imposter had left the apartment with both

of Langley’s cell phones, his keys and wallet.

When Langley called the bank he had discovered
the imposter had already racked up $1,000

in bills on his credit cards.

Langley would find Mike Portnoy’s website
and email the drummer letting him know someone

was impersonating him around the city.

Soon enough more gay men would come forward
detailing their encounters with the impersonator.

According to Dreamtheatre.net one person who
came in contact with the imposter would claim

& I quote “I wanted to somehow get word
to Mike, that there’s a guy in NYC who is

pretending to be Mike, picking guys up at
bars, restaurants, and on the street, convincing

them that he’s Mike Portnoy, the world famous
drummer from Dream Theater… (he has all

their music CD’s, knows every beat of every
song, and the words, and has Mike’s schedule,

both past and present down to a “T”)…

He says that he’s been struggling with his
sexuality lately, t

It wasn’t only gay men the impersonator
fooled as it was other musicians as well.

The NY Post detailed a music promoter and
singer named Ray Freeman who fronted the band

Block 16.

He met the imposter at a bar called Finally

It would turn out that Freeman’s band was
in need of a drummer and the imposter jumped

at the chance to jump behind the drum kitthe

According to Finally Fred’s bartender who
told the post

“He drank here all week but never paid his
tab” – which amounted to $70 –

When Freeman saw the imposter again, he would
tell the NY Post

“He told us that his mother was dying of
cancer, his wife was divorcing him and that

Dream Theater had canceled its tour because
of the iraq war,” “So I kind of felt sorry

for him.”

Freeman and his band members from Block 16
felt so bad for the fake Portnoy that they

let him sleep on their couches.

When it came time for them to jam with the
imposter, it was apparent from the start he

wasn’t a drummer.

On march 28, 2003 at their first rehearsal
Freeman recalled

He was and i quote “without his own sticks
or any of the charts he said he’d written,

Freeman described the impersonator’s drumming
as “worse than my grandmother,” That’s

when Freeman became suspicious and while the
imposter bore some resemblance to the real

mike portnoy is was when Freeman started finding
photos of the real drummer nad look at his

tattoos and compared them to the imposter
that he realized something wasn’t right.

Soon enough Freeman found Portnoy’s website
and emailed the drummer letting him know that

someone was impersonating him.

Freeman also noticed that some of his possessions
were missing including a vintage Les Paul

guitar, his gold chain and a set of house

And On April Fools day 2003 Freeman called
the police and soon enough the authorities

questioned the imposter who turned out to
be a man named Carlos Mendez.

Mendez claimed to the authorities that he
was the real Mike Portnoy, but soon after,

the police took Mendez down to the police
station where the real mike portnoy was waiting

Mendez would be charged with criminal impersonation
and grand larceny with bail being set at $100,000.

But the story doesn’t end there.

One day following the arrest a message would
be posted on Dream Theatrer’s website claiming

that more than 4 victims came forward within
48 hours period.

It would also come out around this time according
to Blabbermouth, that another musician fell

for Mendez scam.

It would be guitarist Chris Cafferty who played
in the band Savatage who took to his own website

and posted his own meeting with Mendez revealing
that even though Savatage played on the same

bill as Dream Theatre in the past he had never
met Portnoy in person.

He would also go on to say “A few days later
in the city I was introduced to who was supposed

to be Mike.

The guy had the whole bar fooled.

Me included.

He obviously did a whole bunch of research
on Mike and his career and family.

He apparently had stolen his wallet and cell

“He had his ID…so who was to know.

The guy knew very serious business details
and family matters of Mike’s.

He was even recognized by people as Mike Portnoy
when I was with him.

He held phone conversations on my phone with
supposed mutual friends…

But It wasn’t until Cafferty got into a
room to jam with Mendez that he realized the

man was an imposter because he couldn’t
play the drums.

Cafferty would also go on to reveal that Mendez
went as far as to contact drum companies and

get free products sent to him using Portnoy’s

Things wouldn’t end there though as in 2006
Mendez resurfaced again.

Portnoy would take to the internet to warn
people about emails he had received about

Mendez impersonating him once again.

That does it for today’s video guys.

Thanks for watching.

Be sure to hit the like button & subscribe
& we’ll see you again on rock n’ roll true


Take care.

Duff McKagan’s Pre-Guns N’ Roses Band Shares New Song

Duff McKagan’s pre-Guns N’ Roses band The Living have released a music video for their song ‘Live By The Gun’. the band which Duff McKagan played in during the early 80’s during his time in his hometown of Seattle put out a record of unreleased songs called “The Living: 1982” just last week. McKagan plays on the track.

The band’s drummer Greg Gilmore is responsible for finding the recordings that make up ‘The Living: 1982.’ They would be released on Pearl Jam guitarist Stone Gossard’s label Loosegroove Records,

McKagan had previously discussed his old band saying:

“Would this even ever get out of our basement? We had something magical then, and it was ours, so who gives an expletive!”

Rare Interview with Slash Surfaces Online

A rare interview with Slash from the UK show Raw Power has surfaced online. It looks like it was done in August of 1991 in the UK, around the time of Izzy Stradlin’s last show and one month ahead of the Use Your Illusion albums coming out. Slash talks about the origins of ‘Live and Let Die’ and ‘Knockin’ On Heavens’ Door.’ Check out the interview below!

story continued below…

Guns N’ Roses Make Major Announcement

Guns N’ Roses announced on social media that they have postponed their 2021 European tour dates. They have been pushed back to 2022 with an additional announcement that those dates will have Gary Clark Jr added as an opener.

Guns N’ Roses Announce Special Guest for 2022

Guns N’ Roses may have cancelled their 2021 European Tour dates, but they have announced on their website that Gary Clarke Jr will be opening for the group next summer.

Guns N’ Roses May Have Cancelled Their Summer Tour?

According to the MyGNRForums, it appears that Guns N’ Roses may have cancelled their summer tour across America. Originally planned for last summer, the tour was of course postponed to 2021. According to one of the posters Dangerous Darren of the Sirius XM Channel Hair Nation supposedly mentioned that the band’s website removed tour dates. I went and checked myself and it appears the dates are shown but when I click on the summer tour dates, ticketmaster’s website claims the event cannot be found. Personally, I doubt the summer tour will happen, but hey there’s Australia and New Zealand to loo forward to this fall.

Slash and Axl Rose Reunited 5 Years Ago Today

Guns N’ Roses fans were shocked to see and hear Axl Rose and Slash playing together for the first time since 1993, when the group did a surprise gig at the Troubadour on April 1, 2016. To celebrate the band posted some footage of the gig on Instagram. Check it out here.

Guns N’ Roses Release Pro-Shot Footage of First Reunion Gig

Guns N’ Roses posted some pro-shot footage of their gig at the Troubadour on April 1, 2016. It marked the first reunion gig featuring Axl Rose, Slash and Duff McKagan since 1993. Check out the footage here.

Slash Posts Adorable Birthday Message to Angus Young of AC/DC

Guns N’ Roses guitarist Slash posted an adorable birthday message to Angus Young of AC/DC on Instagram. Check it out here!

Rock Legend Alice Cooper Discusses Guns N’ Roses

Shock rocker Alice Cooper gave an interview recently where he revealed how one of his favourite tracks was a Guns N’ Roses song. He would say the following about ‘Welcome to the Jungle.’

story continued below…

“We took them on their very first tour and I knew how great that band was. And this album (1987’s Appetite For Destruction) might have been one of the greatest debut albums ever.”

Matt Sorum’s Upcoming Book Gets New Cover & Release Date

Guns N’ Roses former drummer Matt Sorum autobiography was supposed to be released around the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic, but has since been pushed back. It was announced this week that the book would be getting a new cover and release date. Check out the new cover below. The release date has now been pushed back to September 7th of this year with signed pre-orders starting in August. You can get the singed pre-orders with bonuses here.

story continued below…

Double Talkin' Jive
Double Talkin’ Jive By Matt Sorum

Pro-Shot Footage of Frank Ferrer Released Online For His Birthday

Guns N’ Roses celebrated the recent birthday of drummer Frank Ferrer with some pro-shot footage of him beating the skins. Check it out here.

Alice in Chains Forgotten Glam Past

Today on Rock N’ Roll True Stories they take a look at Alice in Chains forgotten glam past. It included a band frontman Layne Staley played in called ‘Sleze’ and then ‘Alice N’ Chains.’ Check out the story below!

People often forget that Alice in Chains was the first so called grunge band from seattle to have a record go gold with 1990’s Facelift. In fact, i’ve done a whole video on facelift and the making of that album, the link is down below. But one other thing people often forget about alice in chains is that their roots were a glam metal band. In today’s video lets explore the glam history of Alice in Chains.

The history of alice in chains really started in 1984 when singer when Layne Staley successfully auditioned for a band named Sleaze thanks to his brother who had an in with the band. Originally a drummer, Layne had transitioned to a singer. The audition would happen in the basement of one of the members of Sleze with the Atlantic writing “before playing together, the band members noticed his tall stature, soft-spoken demeanour, and that he was very much dressed for the part of a rock musician, with band names like “Ozzy” or “Mötley Crüe” written on his pants in bleach. This audition was said to have taken place sometime in 1984. The lineup of Sleze was made up of drummer Carl Bergstrom, guitarists Johnny Bacolas, Ed Semanate as well as bassist Byron Hansen. The first song they played with Layne was a cover of the Motley crue song “looks that kill”
The members of Sleaze were blown away by Layne’s audition, not just because he could sing in key, but because he had his own unique style as well. He would get the job as the singer of the band. Sleze mostly played cover songs and was a glam rock band. Sleze’s live shows mostly attracted women and it saw them hrowing roses into the audience to the women and a friend would even come on stage with a mirror so the members could freshen up. Layne would come on stage riding a big wheel that had the word the “Laynemobile”written on it, which was a spoof of Judas Priest frontman Rob Halford riding a motorcycle on stage.

The band’s wardrobe was inspired by a friend of there’s named Lisa Rammell who told David De Sola in the book ‘Alice in Chains the Untold Story.’ “They would wear my pink and black spandex pants. I had a huge collection of belts and lace globes and tank tops and necklaces and sarves. I did their hair, taught them how to do their makeup and they looked like Poison out there.” The band would even meet ahead of gigs at a local Denny’s and plan their onstage moves.

By 1985 Layne had gotten a job at a place called the Music bank, which was a building that housed a number rehearsal spaces that were open 24/7. In addition to that it was pretty common for musicians to live there as well.

And by 1986 Sleze felt confident enough to record their first demo. That dem o would feature glammy songs include ‘lip lock rock’ and ‘fat girls.’ Tim Branom who produced Sleze first demo recalled working with Layne on his vocals telling david de sola
“”I worked with layne for months on his vocals. I was able to afford to go to maestro david kyle for lessons, but layne wasn’t so he would come a few times a week to my house to my house and we could go over the cassette tapes of my vocal warm ups. After he had done this for six months, the notes just flowed out effortlessly. Layne took a serious interest in working on his vocals as well because according to Branom it would save the band money in the studio. “ later on in layne’s career he would study under david kyle who also taught Geoff Tate of Queensryche, as well as Ann Wilson of Heart.

By 1986 the group soon had discussions about changing their name to It is said that credit for the name Alice in Chains goes to Slaughter Haus 5 singer Russ Klatt. At a party in 1986 Johnny Bacolas ran in to Klatt. And according to De Sola the pair chatted about changing Sleze’s name and Layne and Bacolas had previously designed backstage passes for their band that read “Sleze Welcome to Wonderland Tour.” Soon enough the pair were talking about Alice in Wonderland which warped into Alice in Bondage and Klatt said the words ‘Alice in Chains.’ The members liked the name and thought for their logo they could have a women dressed up in bndage but it also raised some concerns about the marketability of the band and some members parents weren’t so thrilled with the idea so they ended up modifying it to ‘Alice N’ Chains.’. Since this happened in 1986, it’s unlikely that guns n’ roses had any impact on the name change since appetite for destruction came out until 1987.

By the early part of 1987 Sleze’s demo was finished and copies were being sent out to friends and even local radio station KCMU played their music. Sleze also ended up having a ameo in the movie ‘Father Rock.’

Life at the Music Bank where Layne was working and living featured a lot of drugs, but one drug that wasn’t heavily used by the musicians living there. Darrell Vernon who played in another band at the time but was living at the music bank told de sola “Back then he was very against drugs, but were doing just about everything else.” In fact Layne’s substance abuse was so alarming to his bandmates that according to the same book in 1987 they arranged a band meeting to confront the singer as it was also affecting his live performances. Fast forward to May 1, 1987 Alice N’ Chains were playing a show at the Tacoma Little Theatre and in the audience that night was guitarist Jerry Cantrell.

Up until this point Jerry had bounced between Washington State and Texas before coming back home to Tacoma. By 1987 he played in band named Phoenix, before they changed their name to Diamond Lie. Several months after seeing Layne perform live for the first time It was around this time Jerry suffered to family tragedies in his life, first his grandmother died and then his mother passed awa six months later, from cancer. Apart from suffering from depression due to these life changing events, Cantrell’s bandmates noticed two distinct changes to the young guitarist’s personality The first, was that his songwriting got much darker and rather than writing songs about partying, he soon started writing songs about the harsh reality of life. The second was that he had great foresight when it came to rock n’ roll and what the net big thing was going to be.. While his bandmates were worshipping Kiss he knew of up and coming bands like Guns N’ Roses and Poison long before they blew up. It was Jerry’s dominating demeanor according to his bandmates that resulted in Diamond Lie breaking up. Most of the songs the band had been working on sounded like Dokken and were mostly the creation of Cantrell. In the aftermath of Diamond Lies breakup Jerry soon found himself playing in a different band called Gypsy Rose with bassist Mike Starr. Their time in the band was pretty short lived as both members would be fired for not having good enough equipment.

By August of 1987 Layne met Jerry at a party and it was around this time Jerry was homeless after being leaving his family’s house. Layne would recall in a mid 90’s interview “I met jerry at a party just out of the blue. I didn’t think he was the coolest guy in the world or anything. He had no family in the area so he’s kind of struggling didn’t have an mone or a place to stay or anything and me being completely drunk just offered a total stranger a place to stay and clothes and foo. I think two days later he moved his stuff into the rehearsal room that i was working out of” he’d remember.

Not long after Jerry started crashing at the music bank that Alice N’ Chains broke up. Layne’s drug use was cited in the same book as one of the reason’s the band called it quits. Soon after Layne drifted into another band with his Alice N’ Chains bandmate Carl Bergstrom who joined another musician named Terry Holt who was from Los Angeles whose music was described as “semi industrial, kind of hard funk, heavyish rock combination”.” There band would be called 40 years of hate. It was also during this time that Jerry wanted to start a new band. Layne gave Jerry the name and number of drummer Sean Kinney and hooked up again with bassist Mike Starr. It was a small world given that Kinney at the time was dating mike starr’s sister. And Layne would jam with the band on the condition that jJerry play guitar in his new project. Jerry and Mike and Sean wanted layne to join their band full-time but layne was still playing in his other band at the time.

During the time Jerry and Layne were playing in 40 years of Hate Holt was going back and forth between LA and Seattle playing in another band at the time and disappeared to LA for almost nine months With Layne still having committed full time to Jerry, Sean and Mike they devised a plan to get Layne to change his mind. They would tell Layne they were auditioning full time singers and well i’l llet Jerry Cantrell to tell the rest of the story. ok. So we’re like how do we get him to quit the rest of his side projects or whatever and we’re like let’s just start trying out singers in his room. Hahaha Cold blooded. You know, but he couldn’t really argue with it either. He wasn’t really mad about it, but he was kind of a little irked i think, but we put an ad like in the i think in the Rocket, the local music mag or whatever you know band looking for blah blah blah, must have equipment so we we we had a couple of days where we just had a trade of idiots come in into the room that were just horrible. One guy was like a male stripper he was like bright red hair and he had the spandex and the handkerchiefs all the way down to his feet kind of trying to be a knock off David Lee Roth, but just horrible couldn’t sing worth a []. We tried out a couple guys out and he was like the last one and Layne was working the desk so these guys would walk through and then he’d get to hear through the wall us kind of trying to play with him and after that last dude, the male stripper guy he came down and said he said alright i’m in. Alright, I can’t let, i can’t let you guys be playing with these [] guys. You know and we’re like we weren’t really serious, we just wanted to get you pissed off enough to join and he’s like well you got me i’m so he quit all his other bands and that’s how we started.

It was during this time that the band called themselves several names including Jerry’s old monicker Diamond Lie before finally landing on their name Alice in Chains. Once Layne committed the band recorded a demo at a studio in a tree house. This demo would be recorded in 1988 and become known as the tree house tapes. By 1989 Alice in Chains was generating airplay on local station KISW and gaining buzz in various musica publications as the next big band to come out of seattle. However there was one seattle publication, the rocket who despised the band, so much that they didn’t give the band any press coverage in hopes of stifling their career. In fact Grant Alden who worked for the rocket would tell author greg prato in the book Grunge is Dead “i thought Alice in Chains were posers. There was an organic scene and sound, which did develop in seattle, alice in chains looked around at what was happening and changed who they were. It was like soundgarden-lite. They had the same management they’d clearly been watching soundgarden a lot it was the same stage movies. It just wasn’t honest.
Jerry Cantrell would refute these comments in the same book saying “everybody starts emulating someone else, that’s just the way it is. You take the best elements of stuff that turns you on and you add your own thing” he’d say.

Local music managers Kelly Kurtis and Susan Silver who managed Mother Love and Soundgarden helped Alice in Chains land a deal with Columbia Records in late 1989. But it wasn’t an easy negotiation. The band spent almost half a year negotiating with the label and in the end they walked away retaining 100% of their publishing, something a lot of other bands didn’t get.That does it for today’s video guys thanks for watching. If you want to know what happened next to Alice in Chains check out my video on the making of their album Facelift and their subsequent EP SAP.